Not British County Flags – Myths And Misapprehensions.

County councils are commonly awarded coats of arms, from the College of Arms (England and Wales) and the Court of the Lord Lyon (Scotland). Such coats of arms are the property of the respective council as the arms holder or “armiger”; this rule of ownership applies to individuals and administrative bodies alike. Coats of arms generally contain several elements, the main one being a shield bearing a distinct pattern of colours and various devices or “charges” unique to that set of arms. Around the shield there are usually supporters “holding” the shield, a crest above it, which is another distinct device and several other additional features. Whilst coats of arms are generally found in static environments, adorning documents, chamber walls and other property, the design found on the central shield in this arrangement may also be deployed in cloth form, as a “banner of the arms” or armorial banner. Originally, mirroring the typical dimensions of a shield, such banners were usually square in shape, to accommodate the designs found on them but in practice modern armorial banners tend to be produced as standard rectangular flags. Being the same design as found on the arms, the same limitation on use applies to armorial banners, as it does to the original arms from which they derive. Thus, the armorial banner flown by a council, formed from its coat of arms, remains its sole property, albeit that it is deployed in flag form; it represents only the council who owns the design it bears.
A common misconception however, is that such heraldic banners used by county councils, are county flags, representing the county in a general way and available for residents to hoist. This is not the case. In the UK coats of arms are not awarded to towns, cities or counties as entities in their own right but to the administrative bodies, usually councils, which run them. Unless a design has been specifically released to the public by the arms holder i.e. the council, the design remains the property, solely, of that council. This is spelt out in the publication “The Arms of the County Councils of East and West Sussex and the diocese of Chichester” 

untitled.png

This reflects the general rule of heraldry that applies equally to all coats of arms in the UK. In certain cases however, such permission as referred to in the above extract, has been granted in perpetuity, effectively releasing an armorial banner for general use. The specific counties where this permission has been issued are Northumberland, Hertfordshire, Shropshire and Rutland. In a few other cases the local authority which originally received the grant of arms has been abolished, leaving its arms effectively available for use. In such instances, use of the former council’s arms as a county flag is seen as apt and logical because often the design in question is locallly familiar and often already in use by other county organisations. This circumstance has applied in Middlesex, Cumberland, Westmorland, Cheshire, Bedfordshire and Oxfordshire. A few counties have been associated with designs for centuries, owing to their origins as Dark Age kingdoms and the anachronistic ascription of national emblems to them in the heraldic era. Thus the arms used by the councils in these locations predate the councils by several centuries and their take up as county flags by the wider public is not subject to the same prohibition. The counties falling into this category are Essex, Kent and Sussex.

Notwithstanding this general proscription on the usage of council banners, commercial outlets, flag makers and flag sellers, generally flout the rules, which on the whole are not enforced and offer them for sale, described erroneously and misleadingly as “County flag of xxxx”. This practice complicates matters even further. Additionally, some banners of arms often represent local authorities who administer territories that are not counties but short lived and often changing, administrative remits. Regrettably, the terminology has not changed with the often changing structure of local authorities and many of these administrative bodies retain the word “county” in their titles, which serves to confuse the situation even further, “Cumbria County Council” for example implies that there is a county called Cumbria, there is not, this is just an administrative jurisdiction and the several real counties subsumed under this territory continue to exist, as described below.

Another practice that is often seen is the use of council logos, or the shield from council arms, or even the whole achievement with crest and supporters, placed on cloth; again, these are not county flags, by definition they represent only the council in question. Such practice is in contravention of specific guidance to the contrary, outlined for civic authorities in the 1970s!

This confusing state of affairs defines the purpose and usefulness of having a Flag Registry, which identifies and details flags specifically intended for public use, which may be freely produced and flown without any further requirement.

Following is a detailed list of the banners and other council flags that ARE NOT COUNTY FLAGS.

BERKSHIRE COUNCIL

Berkshire’s county flag was registered in 2017. The armorial banner formed from the now defunct council’s coat of arms, pictured at left below,

 

appears not to have ever been used. The former county council, instead, made use of its logo, a watered down version of its coat of arms, on a white cloth, as shown at right above. This very poor design remains commercially available but it is not the Berkshire flag, it was only ever used by the council and only ever represented that body.

BUCKINGHAMSHIRE COUNCIL

This flag

Bucks CC.jpg

is the banner of arms of Buckinghamshire County Council. Whilst it is very similar to the actual county flag, this design is the property of Buckinghamshire County Council and may not be used by anyone but that body. The banner differs from the county flag principally by the inclusion of a yellow bar across the top of the design bearing a representation of a county monument. Whilst the basic design of a divided red and black background with white swan has been associated with the county for centuries, the specific council arms and banner derived from them, were specially created for the council in 1948. The traditional basic version was registered as the county flag in 2011.

CAMBRIDGESHIRE COUNCIL

In 2014, in the midst of the Cambridgeshire county flag competition, the Wisbech Standard reported on a couple

Cambs CC

who failed to understand that the armorial banner of Cambridgeshire County Council, seen in their grasp above, is not the county flag. This design has been used by the council from 1976 to the present day. This banner is inaccurately sold and oaccasionally flown as the ‘Cambridgeshire Flag’, but it actually only represents the County Council and permission is required from this body to fly its banner lawfully. As a result of the 2014 competition Cambridgeshire now has a true county flag which represents the shire and the people of Cambridgeshire, rather than its administrative body, and requires no permission to fly.

CUMBRIA COUNCIL

This

Cumbria CC.jpg

is the banner of arms of the Cumbria County Council. This body administers two counties and parts of two other counties but it is not a county itself and its banner of arms is NOT a county flag. There are four county flags in this area;

Cumberland

Westmorland

Lancashire (Furness)

Yorkshire (Sedbergh)

Because of the similarity of the name of the county of Cumberland and the administration of Cumbria, this flag is sometimes described as the flag of Cumberland – this is not correct, the true Cumberland flag is shown at the above link.

DEVON COUNCIL

Flying here

DEVON CC.jpg

is the banner of the arms of Devon County Council. It is the property of the county council so may not be used by anyone else. Stylistically it also does not make an effective county flag with its fine details at the top which are indiscernible from any distance and it is insufficiently distinct, a red lion is hardly a unique charge! The actual county flag of Devon was chosen in a competition in 2003.

DORSET COUNCIL

This

Dor CC.png

is the banner of arms of Dorset County Council. It is not the county flag of Dorset as it represents only the county’s administration, not the county itself. Furthermore, as the design of the council’s arms and armorial banner, derive from the national, or royal, arms of England and France, it has no specific Dorset county symbolism so is particularly inappropriate to fly, to represent the county of Dorset. Hence a new flag, specifically designed to represent the county, with elements purposefully chosen to symbolise it, was adopted in 2008, as the winner of a county flag competition. 

DURHAM COUNTY COUNCIL

This armorial banner

DCC1.jpg

represents Durham County Council. Formerly, in the absence of an actual County Durham flag, this banner was occasionally used to represent the county; an unlawful practice as the banner has never been released to the public. Additionally, use of this design is inappropriate as administrative rearrangements in 1974 meant that large swathes of County Durham were no longer administered by Durham County Council, whilst conversely, portions of Yorkshire were transferred to its administrative remit and this change was reflected in the arms that were redesigned at this time, which thenceforward included a white rose from Yorkshire. The flag formed of these arms is the property of the council and may not be used by anyone else. As the council does not administer the whole territory of the county, its banner cannot represent the whole county even if it were available for general public usage; the banner does, however, include a charge symbolic of Yorkshire which is not relevant to a flag intended to represent County Durham. Indeed it is highly inappropriate! Accordingly a new flag was revealed in 2013, the winner of a competition specifically intended to create one, to represent the true County Durham.

EAST SUSSEX COUNCIL

Seen here,

10259978_360774304094066_7907191976694238258_n

is the banner of East Sussex County Council from 1975 to the present day. This banner is commonly miss-sold and flown as the ‘East Sussex Flag’. This is untrue. There is no such county as East Sussex. East Sussex is just a designation for an administrative remit covering part of the county of Sussex, along with several others. This armorial banner represents the council alone and as a heraldic banner, permission is required to raise this flag. There is only one Sussex and it has only one flag.

Please note that a very detailed description of the situation as it applies in Sussex is available here.

GLOUCESTERSHIRE COUNCIL

Glos CC2.jpg

Above is the banner of the arms of Gloucestershire County Council. It is not the county flag of Gloucestershire as it represents only the council whose arms it features and no one but the council itself, may lawfully fly this banner. The actual county flag was registered in 2008, following a competition organised by the Gloucestershire High Sheriff to celebrate the county’s milennium.

GREATER MANCHESTER COUNCIL

The flag flying here,

GM1

GM2

is the banner of the arms of Greater Manchester County Council. This body existed between 1974 and 1985. The extinct body was a short lived administration whose banner represented itself alone. This banner is today commonly miss-sold and often flown, as the county flag of ‘Greater Manchester’: it is not. Greater Manchester was/is an administrative convenience, this area has 3 official county flags –
Lancashire; Cheshire; Yorkshire some of whose territory fell under the administration of the erstwhile Greater Manchester Council but whose territorial integrity as counties was never affected by this administrative convenience. The true county flags represent the shires and people of Lancashire, Cheshire and Yorkshire respectively, rather than an administrative body.

HAMPSHIRE COUNCIL

 

Hampshire is the only county on the South Coast without a flag. The banner of arms of Hampshire County Council seen above, represents just that body, it is not the county flag. There are a number of proposals for the county flag located here.

HEREFORDSHIRE COUNCIL

Herefordshire is one of only four English counties without a registered flag. The armorial banner of Herefordshire Council

 

is sometimes seen. This banner is commonly mis-sold and flown as the ‘Herefordshire Flag’, however this is not true as it only represents the County Council and to fly it requires permission from that body. Whilst there are several features on the design that are representative of the county, the lion whose form is taken from the Royal Banner of England, is found on the arms of Norfolk and Dorset county councils and is not remotely unique nor is it specifically representative of the county, being found on arms across the country, the continent and the World. Whilst, sadly, Herefordshire doesn’t currently have a registered county flag, some proposed ideas may be found here. A true county flag would represent the shire and the people of Herefordshire, rather than an administrative body, and would not require permission to fly. Another flag

joke

often labelled as “Herefordshire county flag” is a spurious creation that originated as a joke, as reported here http://www.herefordtimes.com/…/4889787.Internet_joke_creat…/ It also includes the coat of arms of Herefordshire County Council so is subject to the same provisions as the council’s actual armorial banner; it is not registered, nor well designed and is certainly not the county flag of Herefordshire.

LEICESTERSHIRE COUNCIL

LeicsCC

There is as yet no Leicestershire county flag. The flag often marketed as the county flag of Leicestershire in fact represents only Leicestershire County Council and it requires permission from the council to fly. This body additionally does not administer the whole county, the city of Leicester itself is self-administering, so the symbols of the county council cannot represent the entire county, by definition. A report about this here http://www.leicestermercury.co.uk/…/story-120375…/story.html. Some suggested designs for a Leicestershire county flag are detailed here.

NORFOLK COUNCIL

Flying here,

 

we see the armorial banner of Norfolk County Council, from 1904 to the present day. This banner is incorrectly sold and flown as the ‘Norfolk Flag’; it actually represents just the Norfolk County Council. There is no general permission to fly this armorial banner. Norfolk only has one county flag which represents the shire and the people of Norfolk, rather than an administrative body, and does not require permission to fly.

NORTHAMPTONSHIRE COUNCIL

Until September 11th 2014 there was no Northamptonshire flag. Occasional use was made of an entirely spurious creation, shown above left, which takes the supporters from Northamptonshire council’s full achievement of arms, plus a Tudor rose and places them on a Saint George’s cross in an arbitrary arrangement that has no local tradition. A second flag placed the full achievement of the council’s arms on a white cloth, replete with writing. This ignores both true heraldic practice, which is to form a banner of the arms thus

NCC Banner

( which itself would be unavailable for the public to fly!) and specifically contradicts advice to avoid such awful designs, outlined for civic authorities, in the 1970s! It also contravenes one of the most recognised and oft quoted tenets of good flag design, namely, “…..Avoid the use of writing of any kind… ” Fortunately, Northamptonshire County Council recognised the issues surrounding the poor “flags” available, purporting to represent the county and sponsored a competition which elicited a true Northamptonshire county flag.

OXFORDSHIRE COUNCIL

Oxfordshire County Council was awarded arms in 1949 which were blue with a red ox head in the centre of two wavy white stripes representing the River Thames flowing through the county. In 1974 the original council was replaced by a new body with a much expanded remit that included large swathes of Berkshire and a new set of arms was created for this new council. These new arms, in the form of an armorial banner

OX CC banner.png

are sometimes found on sale as the county flag of Oxfordshire, they are not! This armorial banner represents only the county council of Oxfordshire, whose adminstrative scope encompasses much more than just the county of Oxfordshire so even if the banner were available to the general public, it is not representative of the true county. In 2017 a campaign was launched, supported by seventeen Oxfordshire groups, to see the design of the original council’s arms, formally acknowledged by the Flag Institute as the county flag was launched. Another version of the modern council’s armorial banner

green

unaccountably using a green background colour, is also sometimes seen but this again, is not the Oxfordshire county flag.

A further design

has been promoted as a potential county flag by the Oxfordshire Association. Named the Saint Frideswide Cross, for the county’s traditional heroine, it features a white cross against a countercharged blue and green background, with the first quarter in green. An attractive design but a novel creation, the proposal could have achieved registration only by winning a competition but no such event was ever organised and given the county’s existing above traditional emblem, this was in any case unnecessary.

SOMERSET COUNCIL

somerset-cc-logo-flag

Somerset has been associated with a dragon for millennia. In 2013 a dragon was on the winning design in the county flag competition. Prior to this, the arms of the local county council, awarded in 1911, had also featured a dragon, grasping a blue mace representative of authority and reflecting the county’s ancient association with the symbol. In the late 20th century the council deployed a logo which included the dragon from its arms under the name SOMERSET. In the absence of a county flag before 2013, this logo, placed on a white cloth, was sometimes flown. This design, seen above, is not the county flag of Somerset, it lacks the county’s traditional red and gold colour scheme; the artwork is of minimal quality; the mace specifically symbolises the authority of the county council. Additionally, use of script undermines the flag’s symbolic power and looks ugly. Such usage also contravenes perhaps the best recognised tenets of good flag design, namely, “….Avoid the use of writing of any kind… “

SOUTH YORKSHIRE COUNCIL

South Yorkshire describes an administrative area covering territory in Yorkshire’s West Riding. It is not a county. The council uses a modern logo type flag

souyork

which represents only the council itself and nothing else. The flag also features letters, in direct contravention of probably the most widely quoted advice on good flag design, namely, “…Avoid the use of writing of any kind… ”

STAFFORDSHIRE COUNCIL

The flag on display here,

staffs cc

is the banner of Staffordshire County Council from 1931 to the present day. Whilst   commonly miss-sold and flown as the ‘Staffordshire Flag’, this actually only represents  the County Council. This council banner was released to the public by the county council in the midst of moves to secure a flag for the county but the council’s remit did not extend to great swathes of the true shire so by definition its armorial banner could not represent true Staffordshire. Additionally, the lion passant which features on the council arms and its armorial banner, is actually a royal emblem, which requires permisison to use, so it’s doubtful that it would have been permissible to register a design which enjoys such legal protection and such a restriction would have fallen outside the registration requirement of being freely available to the general public, to make and fly. In an online poll held by the Flag Institute in March 2016 the Staffordshire county flag was chosen over the council’s banner by a considerable margin. The design, submitted by the Staffordshire Heritage Group, is a traditional county pattern associated with Staffordshire for several centuries and actually the basis for the Staffordshire County Council arms, which differ by the addition of the lion passant from the royal arms of England, representing the authority wielded by the council, handed down by the crown and by having a much more visible and well designed Stafford Knot, the outstanding county emblem. The registered county flag represents the shire and the people of Staffordshire, rather than just the administrative body which runs a small portion of the county of Staffordshire.

SUFFOLK COUNCIL 

suff-cc

There is no Suffolk county flag. An armorial banner of the Suffolk County Council would look like the picture above but the council eschews standard heraldic procedure and instead places the shield from its coat of arms on a yellow flag

 

NEITHER is the county flag of Suffolk and both represent only the local council, NOT the county of Suffolk. The commonly flown design also ignores the specific guidance to avoid such arrangements, outlined for civic authorities in the 1970s!

Another flag used in the county features the shield of Saint Edmund’s arms placed at the centre of Saint George’s cross

bulstrode

This design has not been registered and as it is almost identical to the century old, registered flag of East Anglia, of which region, Suffolk is a part, it could not be registered as it is not sufficiently distinct. In fact it is actually based on the East Anglia flag. Additionally this design is copyrighted

img_9716

so it is automatically ineligible for registration. Some suggested ideas for a Suffolk county flag can be found here.

SURREY COUNCIL

The flag seen here

sur-cc

is the banner of arms of the Surrey County Council as constituted since 1965. In this year a substantial portion of the county’s territory, formerly administered by Surrey council, was removed from its remit and these new arms were awarded in 1974 for the newly constituted body. Therefore, not only does this armorial banner represent only the council as a body, rather than the county itself but additionally it does not even apply to the whole county. However, in the absence of a registered county flag this armorial banner was occasionally used as a Surrey flag albeit that as council property, no one other than the council had the right to use it. In 2014 a true Surrey flag was registered, to represent the entirety of the county, derived from a traditional local emblem.

TYNE AND WEAR COUNCIL

T&W

‘Tyne and Wear’ is not a county. This name refers to an administrative area that covered a stretch of territory straddling the border of County Durham and Northumberland. Residents of this locality should fly either the flag of Northumberland or the flag of County Durham. The “flag” shown above represented only the body which administered this area for a short period before being replaced by another arrangement. Being basically a council logo it lacks the vexillographic merit found in the majority of actual county flags.

WARWICKSHIRE COUNCIL

WCC banner

Warwickshire acquired its county flag in August 2016. The county has been associated with the symbol of a bear and ragged staff for centuries, following its initial adoption as a family badge by the Earl of Warwick. The same design was adopted in a slightly amended form and with a gold chief or upper section by Warwickshire County Council in the twentieth century. This design, in the form of a banner of the arms, seen above, has been erroneously marketed as the county flag, even though it actually only represents Warwickshire County Council and there is no general right to fly it. In fact Warwickshire Council expressly advises that the design may only be used by the council itself, stating “These arms are specific to the County Council, and may only be used by it.” Hence a newly realised flag, bearing the ancient county emblem of white bear and ragged staff against a red background, reflecting a depiction found on John Speed’s 17th century map of the county, was registered as the Warwickshire flag.

WEST SUSSEX COUNCIL

This armorial banner

west-sussex-council

is occasionally seen flying and sometimes found on sale, described as the “county flag of West Sussex”. It is not a county flag and there is no such county as West Sussex, which actually designates one of several administrative bodies that run matters in the county of Sussex. The photo actually depicts a banner of the arms of West Sussex council between 1889 and 1974. The body which owned these arms no longer exists, having been replaced by another council, which uses another set of arms but neither set has ever been released for public use and in any case they do not represent any county: there is only one Sussex and it has only one flag.

The council itself in 2007, promoted another, poorly designed flag

img_0001-3

to celebrate Sussex Day.  Not only is this NOT a county flag, it is also badly designed and quite unecessary. It includes a monochromatic depiction of the West Sussex council’s arms, highlighting just one administrative remit in the county and thereby wholly undermining the concept of Sussex Day, the Day of the county as a whole.

Please note that a very detailed description of the situation as it applies in Sussex is available here.

WORCESTERSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL

wcc-banner-jpg

Above is the armorial banner of Worcestershire County Council, it represents only that body. It may not be flown without permission and it is NOT the county flag. The actual county flag was the winner of a 2013 competition.